Without beating about the bush: this serial doesn’t have a very good reputation, described variously as ‘tedious’ and ‘leaden and unengaging’. In context, it’s neither of these things: it’s the first time Jo has gone into space (she gets a lovely moment of wonder as she gazes out of the porthole of the Skybase), and the first time the show treats the breaking of the Earth exile format as routine (there’s none of the lengthy set-up of Colony in Space, the Doctor accepts he can travel in the TARDIS so long as it’s as an agent of the Time Lords, and Jo has no qualms about going with him).

Continue reading →

It’s all go in this final episode, which is a vast improvement over last week’s misfire. Predictably, the Sea Devils prove as untrustworthy associates to the Master as the Nestenes, the Mind Parasite and the Axons, and he ends up locked in a cell with the Doctor who, fortunately, has reversed the polarity of the neutron flow (yay!) to destroy the Sea Devils and their base before they can take over the world.

Continue reading →

This is a let down after a lead up of four really entertaining, funny episodes. While Malcolm Hulke has never tried to hide this is a companion piece to Doctor Who and the Silurians, I think here the comparison works very much not in The Sea Devils‘ favour. Partly this is because the dilemma is so unchanged from the earlier story. But largely it’s because the Sea Devils themselves aren’t given the space to become an equal and opposite culture to humankind, as the Silurians were. Instead, the Master takes the place of the arrogant “Young Silurian” in arguing against the elder Sea Devil’s willingness to negotiate, and so the Sea Devils themselves are reduced to props in the ongoing enmity between the two Time Lords. They look quite good, and their whispery, rattling voices are better than the Silurians’ warbling, but the Sea Devils just aren’t as interesting.

Continue reading →

Two of the classic clip-compilation moments happen early in this episode. First, the Doctor hurls himself on barbed wire, and uses the sonic screwdriver to detonate a minefield to scare off a pursuing Sea Devil (probably best not to ask why he didn’t just blow up all the mines straight away rather than than creeping slowly through them). Later, in a bigger and better repeat of the previous cliffhanger, a host of Sea Devils rise from the sea, at dusk, to attack the castle.

Continue reading →

The long recap of the fight sequence from the end of Episode Two indicates that this is going to be a bit thin, and the script is mostly just vamping, spending loads of time getting the Doctor out of handcuffs; Trenchard delaying Captain Hart’s investigations, and a submarine in danger from the monsters we already know are behind the missing boats. In theory, this is infamous middle-episode padding.

Continue reading →

This episode does most of the heavy linking to connect The Sea Devils with Doctor Who and the Silurians. On the plus side, this includes some call-backs to many of the most memorable moments of the earlier story: the man whose mind is broken by an encounter with a race memory, and the Doctor’s first encounter with a “Sea Silurian” where he again offers the hand of friendship and, beautifully, tells the monster not to be scared.

Continue reading →

I think it’s a display of the show’s increasing self-confidence that it’s able to start doing ongoing stories than run across multiple serials. We haven’t seen the Master for eight months and as many episodes. This picks up his storyline from the end of The Dæmons, with him in prison, but predictably plotting his escape. And while it might have been safe to do this as a Season Eight throwback, instead it’s a sequel to a Season Seven story minus UNIT, with the Royal Navy standing in (which means the Doctor is again in a slightly uncomfortable relationship with military authority, rather than the increasingly cosy partnership with the Brigadier).

Continue reading →

The mystery plot is resolved within the first minute: Arcturus was the traitor helped by Hepesh, who is trying to stir up interplanetary war. As a result, there’s a little less creeping around corridors and caves than the last three episodes, as this instead focuses on Hepesh’s palace coup. It’s all very sound and neatly ties up all the loose ends (including the Doctor’s control of the TARDIS, which he now believes was engineered by the Time Lords) at the expense of some of the colour of the earlier weeks.

Continue reading →

It’s great again to see Katy Manning presented with more material, including quite a lengthy scene with David Troughton. But it also highlights the downside of making Jo a more prominent character than most previous female companions, because that scene involves the King asking Jo to marry him. Her independence means she’s fair game as a love interest, and the King will soon be followed by several more suitors until she’s inevitably married off. Elsewhere, she again gets to save the Doctor’s bacon – or so she thinks – by leaping in with burning torch to scare off Aggedor. This is great; her ditzy accidental hypnotism a few moments later isn’t.

Continue reading →

These negotiations are more on-and-off than the Brexit ones. While the previous episode focused on divisions in the royal court of Peladon, this turns to the squabbling delegates. Arcturus and Alpha Centauri appear panicked by the curse of Aggedor, and even the Ice Warriors are disconcerted. It’s all a pretext for the Doctor to show his unreconstructed views on monsters, telling Jo, ‘I know the Ice Warriors, Jo. They’re a savage and a warlike race.’ Fascinatingly, it’s his prejudice that drives the plot, with Jo refusing to accept their guilt without looking for evidence, and the Doctor overlooking the obvious suspect in all this because he’s too busy going toe to toe with Izlyr.

Continue reading →