Initially, the episode continues to dangle the possibility that Waterfield might be a rival member of the Doctor’s people. Jamie wonders whether he might have invented a time machine like the TARDIS – which the Doctor dismisses as unlikely, even though Jamie’s almost spot on. And Waterfield’s angry confrontation with the Dalek that kills Kennedy makes him appear even more Doctorish. When he wakes up from the knock-out gas in Maxtible’s house, the Doctor is clearly disturbed to learn that he’s been captured by the Master, which is a lovely opportunity for a ret-con.

Continue reading →

Someone has stolen the TARDIS! It’s been a while since the Ship’s whereabouts has been so central to the story – long gone are the days when getting back to it was the overriding concern. It’s the first hint that the original script editor, David Whitaker, is doing something interesting with a Doctor Who first: a serial consciously designed as a season finale.

Continue reading →

The Doctor and his own Holly Goodhead, Nurse Pinto, have infiltrated the Chameleon space station as the alien master plan approaches its conclusion. As above, so below: on earth the Commandant, Jean and Sam are desperately searching for the comatose bodies of the Chameleons’ victims.

Continue reading →

Another procedural middle episode, which is mainly successful for postponing the climax for another week. The only surprises here are vaguely irrelevant details, like the miniaturisation of the Chameleon’s kidnap victims (discovered in a filing cabinet), and the reveal of the Chameleons’ motivation: a huge explosion on their home planet wiped their identities, and they plan to abduct 50,000 young people to ensure their survival.

Continue reading →

A procedural episode that continues the holding pattern from the last week, albeit with a trip into the medical centre for a change of scenery where the Doctor discovers more sinister duplicates and alien equipment; he continues to wind up the indignant Commandant, and throws out more wild theories about what the Chameleons are doing. Hulke and Ellis throw in a few other flourishes like the Goldfinger style laser cutter to add a few minutes of jeopardy to pass the time, but this is very much a bog-standard capture/escape middle episode.

Continue reading →

Very much more of the same after the first two episodes. By now, the police are involved, the Doctor has turned the tables on the villains, and the Chameleon’s plan to kidnap and replace individuals is clear. If this had been a 50-minute episode from one of the secret agent shows it emulates, this would be the point when there’s a punch up, and a quick tag scene.

Continue reading →

There’s something very disturbing about seeing Anneke Wills playing “Michelle Leuppi from Zurich” quite differently from Polly: a cold, dismissive lack of interest in other people, curt to the Doctor and Samantha Briggs. No wonder the Doctor quickly surmises this isn’t Polly brainwashed – there’s nothing of her personality in Michelle. Then, there’s the double punch of Ben discovering the real Polly’s body sealed like a waxwork inside a crate. It’s a shame this is more or less Will’s final episode, but at least she goes out with an acting challenge. Michael Craze gets less to do – but gets an almost equally brilliant moment of horror when he’s shot as he talks to the Doctor on a video screen, and the Doctor can do nothing to help.

Continue reading →

For the first time since June 1966 the TARDIS has arrived in present-day Britain – and the series has never looked more like a VT episode of The Avengers. This isn’t entirely surprising given it’s the first Doctor Who script by former Avengers writer Malcolm Hulke. Barring the Christmas run-in with the police in The Feast of Steven, it’s the first time the Doctor has had to properly contend with British officialdom (having worked comfortably alongside them in The War Machines) and watching it feels like a sudden premonition of the imminent UNIT years.

Continue reading →

The Macra Terror gets more ordinary and less interesting as it goes on. This final episode consists of the Doctor mucking about with some switches, running through a corridor, and unmasking the Macra to the Pilot – whose response is pretty understated given his entire worldview has just been torn down in front of his face.

Continue reading →

After the previous episode revealed that the Macra are in charge of the colony, this episode sets out to explain why – and it’s a bit garbled, to be honest. The explanation is that the Macra need the human colonists to mine the poison gas they need to survive. But if that’s the case, why are they running the colony like a holiday camp instead of a labour camp? What’s in it for them? It’s not even as if the happy campers are willing collaborators who get to enjoy luxury lifestyles in return for selling out their comrades: they’re in thrall to the Macra, and it seems the miners – who are the ones ensuring the Macra get their gas – who are the rebellious dissidents.

Continue reading →